#013 Is This a Pigeon? Misclassification in Thesis Committees
Why thesis committees misclassify chapters, and what the butterfly can teach us.
Introduction
Thesis committees routinely misclassify chapters [1]. A methods chapter is read as a literature review, a literature review as a cry for help, and an appendix as the actual thesis. We ask whether the problem lies with the chapter or with the committee, and whether adding committee members helps.
Method
Forty committee members were shown a butterfly under standard viva lighting and asked to name it. Responses were coded against ground truth by a blinded entomologist. Assuming each member mislabels independently with probability , the chance that a committee of members labels a chapter correctly is
so every extra member is, formally, an extra opportunity to be called a pigeon.
Results
Thirty-eight members answered pigeon, giving . The remaining two asked whether the butterfly was in scope. Under Equation (1), a standard five-member committee labels a chapter correctly with probability below , which matches the lived experience of every participant we interviewed.
Conclusion
Committees should be kept small, and chapters should announce what they are in the first sentence. Label your figures. Then label them again [2].
References
- Butterfly G. Is this a pigeon? Category errors in academic review. Journal of Ornithological Doubt. 2019;3(1):1-9.
- Anon. Please label your axes. Reviewer Two Quarterly. 2020;12:404.