#014 Stonks: The Line Always Goes Up
A longitudinal study of progress charts that only ever go up.
Introduction
Annual progress reports show a striking regularity: the line always goes up [1]. This holds across disciplines, funding bodies, and students who privately describe the year as a write-off. We identify the estimator responsible and show that it is working exactly as designed.
Method
We collected 120 annual progress charts from three graduate schools. For each chart, the reported trajectory was compared against the underlying progress reconstructed from lab notebooks. Every chart was consistent with the running-maximum estimator
which reports the best moment so far and discards everything after it. Data points that disagreed were described in the reports as outliers.
Results
All 120 lines went up. By construction of Equation (1), everywhere, so no other outcome was possible. Confidence intervals also went up, and then sideways. The largest gap between and was observed in the month before each report was due.
Conclusion
Progress charts measure optimism, not progress. We recommend plotting alongside , and note that no participant agreed to do so. Stonks remain a reliable indicator of stonks [2].
References
- Poole G. Line goes up: a longitudinal study. Helix Letters. 2021;8(4):88-91.
- Man M. Stonks and their discontents. Journal of Optimistic Finance. 2019;1:1.